The Thing That Doesn't Have a Name Yet

By Courtney Carpenter, Founder — BlackSheep Strategic Advisory

Before Scrub Daddy had an Australian audience, it had an American one.

Cult product. Shark Tank origin story. A devoted following built not on clever marketing but on the product doing exactly what it claimed — on surfaces people had tried everything on, with results that made them photograph their sink and post it.

When we started working on the Australian market entry, none of that equity existed here. Zero local data. Zero local awareness. A market that had no idea what Scrub Daddy was, let alone why it should care.

The challenge wasn't the product. The product was exceptional. The challenge was reading what was already moving in the market — finding the signal before anyone else had named it.

What the Signal Actually Looks Like

There is a moment in every market cycle that most people miss entirely.

It exists before the trend report. Before the data. Before the category has a name or a hashtag or a retail buyer who's had three meetings about it.

It exists in small, specific communities where a behaviour is forming — quietly, consistently, without coordination.

In the case of cleaning products in Australia, the signal was this: cleaning content was becoming something.

Not utility content — not "how to get a stain out" — but cleaning content as genuine entertainment.

Communities of people who watched before-and-after videos the way others watched sport. Who followed accounts because the product satisfaction was, genuinely, satisfying to watch. Who gave recommendations with the authority of someone who had tested everything and had opinions.

These communities were small. The mainstream hadn't found them yet. No brand manager's quarterly trend report had cited them. The search terms for the category barely registered.

But the behaviour was real. And it was building.

Why Most Businesses Miss This Stage

Stage 1 is pre-visibility. By definition, the data that organisations use to make decisions — search volume, retailer interest, media coverage, analyst reports — doesn't exist yet. The signal is moving, but it hasn't generated the numbers that decision-makers look for.

Most businesses aren't built to act at Stage 1. Their risk frameworks aren't designed for it. Their approval processes aren't comfortable with "the data doesn't confirm this yet, but here's what I'm seeing." Their instinct is to wait for confirmation.

By the time confirmation arrives, they're not entering the signal. They're entering the noise.

The other problem is instrumentation. The tools most organisations use to track market opportunity are designed to measure what's already visible — search trends, social volume, sales data, category reports. They are, by nature, lagging indicators. They tell you what already happened.

Stage 1 requires a different kind of reading. Niche community behaviour. The way a small group talks about a product — the language they use, the specificity of their claims, the speed with which the conversation spreads within the community without any marketing support behind it. These are leading indicators. They're harder to measure. They require pattern recognition that doesn't come from a dashboard.

What We Were Looking For

With Scrub Daddy, the question wasn't "is there a market for cleaning products in Australia." Obviously there was. The question was: is there a community already forming that will receive this product the way it's been received elsewhere?

The answer was yes. The cleaning content community in Australia was small, engaged, and hungry for products that actually delivered. The word-of-mouth mechanics were already in place. The infrastructure for organic advocacy — the accounts, the communities, the culture of sharing results — existed.

The product didn't need to create the community. It needed to find it.

That's what Stage 1 looks like from the inside: not a gap in the market, but a community waiting for the right product to arrive.

The work is identifying that community before everyone else does — and building the commercial foundation to reach them while the space is still clear.

The Uncomfortable Truth About Early Entry

Acting at Stage 1 is uncomfortable. Not because the signal is unclear — if you're reading the right things, it's often quite clear — but because the confirmation isn't there yet.

You're deciding that the data doesn't support. You're moving before the trend report tells you to. You're committing to a position before anyone else has validated it.

That discomfort is not a sign you're wrong. It's a sign you're early.

The brands that have built market positions — not just market presence — have almost always done it by acting before the evidence was comfortable. By reading the signal before it became noise. By committing to a community before it became a category.

The earliest window in any market cycle is also the quietest. That's not incidental. It's the whole point.

If you're trying to work out whether the window in your category is open or closing — that's exactly the conversation I have.

Book a Boost Your Business session →

Courtney Carpenter is the founder of BlackSheep Strategic Advisory. She works with business owners who are capable, overloaded, and ready to move.